The actions or thoughts that constitute the ultimate sin depend on who you ask, but in the realm of government bureaucracy there is almost unanimous agreement that disagreeing with a superior and accusing him or her of being incorrect is the worst sin of all, and the most unpardonable.
A brave FBI agent has all but accused the top boss in the bureau of being wrong, and while she will pay the price for her honesty when someone in the federal government asks for whistle-blower protection, theyre doomed and they know it weve come a step closer to the truth about who knew what about 9/11.
I was thinking about this after seeing the film The Sum of All Fears.
Tom Clancys Jack Ryan, and the others of his generation, do not fit in at the Central Intelligence Agency. Ryan is convinced that he is right about the new Russian leader, but the hierarchy isnt persuaded. At one point, it looks like he has totally missed the boat, and someone reminds him that he really blew it.
Ryans efforts to get around the bureaucracy show how tough it is for a low-level person to get attention, and how ludicrous it is for the government to brag about how it wants to recruit independent thinkers for agencies that want no one to do any sort of independent thinking.
Bureaucracies, especially of the federal variety, are creatures of habit that resist change and have the means to stop it in its tracks. The country is littered with the wreckage of illustrious careers destroyed trying to pull off reform.
The Postal Service is the model for bureaucratic inertia, and more Postmasters General have taken on the organization than I have hair left on my head, and departed after a year or two shaking their heads in astonishment at how little they were able to accomplish.
Even now, in the current financial crisis, the postal bureaucracy is fighting to maintain the status quo, despite the full knowledge that it will only result in the end of the Postal Service and the loss of their jobs. They just cant help it; theyre trained to fight change.
Unlike The Sum of All Fears, where Ryan has a top boss who sticks up for him, when you take on the federal bureaucracy, you take it on alone. The guardians of the status quo are ready, willing and able to destroy you to protect their turf.
Rowley did a brave thing, and published reports say shes a level-headed agent who knows her way around. It requires a lot of guts to take a stand on principle in a world where keeping your mouth shut and getting with the program guarantees safety and job security.
Shell pay dearly for her audacity, and therell be another round of press-conference reform at the FBI while Rowley gets the bums rush from the Bureau. If its any comfort to her, she did what she was supposed to do, if not by the standards of the FBI bureaucracy, then by the standards the rest of us aspire to.
Vincent F. Safuto is a copy editor for the Press Journal. Reach him at Vincent.Safuto@scripps.com.
--------
